Not a Smart Question: Is Eid Better Here or Back Home? When Life Becomes a Constant Comparison
Almost every Eid season, the same question returns in different forms: Is Eid better back home or in Britain? Has the meaning of Eid been lost in exile? Can a person ever truly feel they belong away from the place where they first learned what home meant?
At first glance, these questions seem innocent enough. But they often rest on a flawed assumption: that people always have complete freedom to choose between one life and another, or that they can somehow suspend their entire existence between two places out of loyalty to a cherished memory.
Life is rarely that simple.
People do not move between countries the way tourists move between hotels. There are circumstances, paths, fate, opportunities and, sometimes, necessities that leave little room for choice. More often than not, people adapt because they must, and then continue moving forward.
That is why endless comparisons between “there” and “here” often become more exhausting than enlightening.
Human Beings Are Not Trees
One of humanity’s greatest strengths is its ability to adapt.
We are not trees condemned to remain rooted in the same soil for our entire lives. We change. We learn. We settle. We form new friendships. We build new routines. And, gradually, we create a sense of familiarity in places where we once arrived as strangers.
Some people portray this ability to adapt as a betrayal of the past. In reality, it is a sign of maturity.
It is difficult to imagine someone spending years in a country — working there, raising children, building relationships and contributing to society — while continuing to treat it as nothing more than a temporary waiting room.
Integration does not require abandoning one’s roots. It means coming to terms with reality. It means respecting the life we are actually living instead of remaining trapped in a never-ending comparison between what was and what is.
Memory Chooses What It Wants to Remember
The problem is that memory is not always fair.
It tends to preserve the warmest images: the voices of relatives, the smell of food, family visits during Eid, and the laughter of childhood. With time, memories often become softer, kinder and more beautiful than the reality from which they emerged.
But no one can live entirely inside memory.
Nostalgia is a wonderful thing when it offers comfort. It becomes a burden when it prevents us from building a stable and fulfilling life in the place where we actually live.
No one should be expected to forget their first home. Yet neither should they spend a lifetime feeling guilty for discovering new sources of joy and belonging elsewhere.
Eid Is Made by People, Not Geography
Eid is not a fixed piece of geography.
It is not the name of a particular city, a specific tradition, or an old street preserved in memory. Eid is a feeling created through relationships, tranquillity, and the ability to share meaningful moments with people we love.
Someone may feel more warmth in a small house in London than in an entire city filled with memories. For others, the opposite may be true.
The point is that this is not a competition between two places. It is a deeply human and emotional relationship with life itself.
Perhaps more importantly, the next generation will build its memories here. They will grow up surrounded by different traditions and different details, and they will cherish them just as we once cherished the details of our own childhoods.
It would be unfair to burden them with the idea that real life happened somewhere else, and that everything they experience is merely a diminished version of a past they never knew.
Acceptance Is Not Surrender
Adapting to the country in which we live is not weakness. Nor is it a surrender of identity.
It is a form of emotional wisdom.
The person who accepts their circumstances and searches for the beauty that exists within them will often find more peace than someone who spends a lifetime resisting, comparing, and treating every year as a temporary detour.
That is why I believe the question, “Which is better — Eid here or Eid back home?” is not really the right question at all.
Life is not a loyalty test between two homelands.
It is a long journey in which we learn how to create meaning, comfort and belonging wherever we happen to find ourselves.
And perhaps that is the deeper meaning of maturity itself:
to stop fighting the life we have, and to begin truly living it.
Read more:
ShortURL ⬇
